
From Local Roots to Scalable Results – Driving Sustainable Growth
Background:
Families and children in the Waterloo Region go hungry daily. In 2017, The Food Bank of Waterloo Region recognized that the need in their community was outpacing the funds they had to support that need at an alarming rate. A change was needed.
Blakely began to partner with The Food Bank of Waterloo Region (FBW) to transform its fundraising program from a single-channel, mail-only approach into a fully integrated, insight-driven strategy — achieving sustained revenue growth and building long-term donor value.
Early on, we focused on foundational direct mail strategy, but quickly expanded to include digital, media, and email integration. As food insecurity in the region intensified — and again during COVID-19 — we helped FBW pivot quickly, execute with agility, and continue building long-term resilience through monthly giving and mid-level donor strategies.
Our Role:
- Agency of record for integrated direct marketing (offline + online)
- Annual strategy, analytics, and donor insights (Rapid Report & Affinity Survey)
- Creative and campaign development for direct mail, email, and digital media
- Monthly donor program development, including the successful “Eat365″ campaign
- Stewardship and retention journeys across all donor segments
- Mid-level and high-value donor strategy development
- CRM and email data integration for targeted, real-time execution
- Annual board reporting on program performance and growth opportunities
What we did:
We knew from the start that we needed to create a slow, intentional strategy for FBW. There was a need to take time to try new things to see what was really going to resonate with their audience. And, just as important, this would allow FBW the time required to build up their list while also introducing channel integration to their program.

Successes & Highlights
$2.5 million
raised through integrated COVID emergency campaigns in 2020
135% increase
in new donors acquired via digital media from 2022-2023
438% increase
in $1,000+ donors from 2019-2023
Revenue & Donor Growth | New Donor Acquisition & Retention | Monthly Sustainer Program | Mid and Major-Level Giving | Donor Insights |
• Overall revenue grew 13% post-pandemic • 280% revenue growth (2018–2022) driven by a digital-first strategy • 2018 Thanksgiving campaign: +10% revenue, double the net year-over-year • 2019 Fall Newsletter raised 50% more than other that year | • New donors increased 105% (2018–2022) • Renewal and new donor retention rates exceeded benchmarks • One-time gift size up 22%, frequency up 3% (2020–2023) | • Sustainers up 50% since 2019; average gift rose by $3. • 43% growth in 24 months without Face-to-Face or Telemarketing. | • Mid-level revenue grew 353%, significantly expanding the Major Gifts pipeline | • Affinity survey showed donors frequently support both their local food bank and the National Food Bank. |


